Letter to the Editors: More on Tina Modotti
To the Editors:
In your September issue, I appreciated the interview with David Jorge about Tina Modotti and Vittorio Vidali, especially the way Jorge countered the slander about Vidali’s role in Spain. Vidali’s short memoir as a Communist senator in Italy includes a prescient forewarning of the difficulties the Communist movement already faced then and would face even more intensely after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Vidali was an independent Communist thinker at a time when the Italian party was criticized for “Eurocommunist” views—that is, for taking a more independent position from the Soviet Union.
In the interview, Jorge states: “As a photographer, Modotti had an artistic sensibility that predated her militant political commitment.” I don’t agree. As I explained in my own essay on Modotti (The Volunteer, December 2025), I believe her effort to develop the modernist style she first learned from Edward Weston took place at the same time as her political development, and that she was able to quickly adapt that modernism to her politics. That was a huge step—and it made her a true pioneer in photography for socially conscious photographers everywhere.
Saludos,
David Bacon, photographer
—Oakland, CA





